Current:Home > InvestThe Supreme Court signals support for a Republican-leaning congressional district in South Carolina-LoTradeCoin
The Supreme Court signals support for a Republican-leaning congressional district in South Carolina
View Date:2024-12-23 14:56:27
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday seemed likely to preserve the Republican hold on a South Carolina congressional district against a claim that it treats Black voters unfairly. The outcome could shape the fight for partisan control of the House of Representatives.
The court’s six conservative justices signaled skepticism with a lower court ruling that ordered South Carolina to redraw a coastal district that is held by Republican Rep. Nancy Mace.
Chief Justice John Roberts said a ruling for Black voters who challenged the district “would be breaking new ground in our voting rights jurisprudence.”
When Mace first won election in 2020, she edged Democratic incumbent Rep. Joe Cunningham by 1%, under 5,400 votes. In 2022, following redistricting driven by the 2020 census results, Mace won reelection by 14%. She is one of eight Republicans who voted to oust Kevin McCarthy as House speaker.
With Republicans holding a thin margin in the U.S. House, the loss or gain of one seat could alter the balance of power after the 2024 elections.
The Republican-led legislature’s 2022 redistricting moved 30,000 Black residents of Charleston out of Mace’s district. The state argued that partisan politics, not race, and a population boom in coastal areas explain the congressional map.
“The General Assembly had no reason to and did not use a racial target. It used political data to pursue its political goals,” lawyer John Gore told the court on behalf of the state.
But the lower court concluded that the state used race as a proxy for partisan affiliation in violation of the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, one of three liberals who sounded sympathetic to the challengers, noted that the old and new districts kept the Democratic-leaning Black voting age population at 17%, low enough to keep electing a Republican representative.
“How do you explain the consistency? I mean, my understanding is that thousands of people were moved in and out of this district, and yet that line, the line concerning the amount of, you know, Black voter -- adult voter participation remained the same,” Jackson said.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh, on the other hand, seemed to have little trouble with the state’s explanations for how the map ended up as it did. Kavanaugh asked what the court should do if it finds the state relied on solid political, rather than racial, data to draw the district.
“If that data is good, should we reverse?” he asked.
Kavanaugh and Roberts split with the other conservatives and joined the liberal justices when the Supreme Court in June said Alabama diluted Black voters’ political power.
Democrats seem likely to gain a seat in Alabama following a court-ordered redistricting that will give Alabama two congressional districts where Black voters comprise a substantial portion of the electorate. A similar pending Louisiana case could lead to a second mostly Black district there, too.
In South Carolina, Black voters wouldn’t be as numerous in a redrawn district. But combined with a substantial set of Democratic-leaning white voters, Democrats could be competitive in the reconfigured district.
Civil rights groups challenged the map in federal court and won a ruling from a unanimous three-judge panel in January.
Leah Aden, arguing in defense of the lower-court ruling, told the justices that “four of the five heaviest Black precincts” were moved out of Mace’s district, while a much lower percentage of majority-white voting precincts were moved.
The lower court put its order on hold to allow the state to appeal to the Supreme Court.
Republican Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey said in January that “we don’t need to draw anything until five members of the Supreme Court say we have to.”
Both sides want a decision by Jan. 1 so that the state can use a congressional map in the 2024 elections that complies with the Supreme Court’s ruling.
veryGood! (3168)
Related
- NFL overreactions: New York Jets, Dallas Cowboys going nowhere after Week 10
- Book excerpt: American Ramble: A Walk of Memory and Renewal
- Kelis Cheekily Responds to Bill Murray Dating Rumors
- Pills laced with fentanyl killed Leandro De Niro-Rodriguez, Robert De Niro's grandson, mother says
- Saving for retirement? How to account for Social Security benefits
- Jennifer Garner and Sheryl Lee Ralph Discuss Why They Keep Healthy Relationships With Their Exes
- Scandoval Shocker: The Real Timeline of Tom Sandoval & Raquel Leviss' Affair
- Minnesota Pipeline Ruling Could Strengthen Tribes’ Legal Case Against Enbridge Line 3
- Nicole Kidman Reveals the Surprising Reason for Starring in NSFW Movie Babygirl
- Marathon Reaches Deal with Investors on Human Rights. Standing Rock Hoped for More.
Ranking
- Worker trapped under rubble after construction accident in Kentucky
- As the Gulf of Mexico Heals from the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill, Stringent Safety Proposals Remain Elusive
- Sister Wives' Gwendlyn Brown Calls Women Thirsting Over Her Dad Kody Brown a Serious Problem
- 5 Seconds of Summer Guitarist Michael Clifford Expecting First Baby With Wife Crystal Leigh
- 'Yellowstone' premiere: Record ratings, Rip's ride and Billy Klapper's tribute
- Helpless Orphan or Dangerous Adult: Inside the Truly Strange Story of Natalia Grace
- Watchdog faults ineffective Border Patrol process for release of migrant on terror watchlist
- These 20 Secrets About the Jurassic Park Franchise Will Find a Way
Recommendation
-
Too Hot to Handle’s Francesca Farago Gives Birth, Welcomes Twins With Jesse Sullivan
-
Drilling, Mining Boom Possible But Unlikely Under Trump’s Final Plan for Southern Utah Lands
-
The Resistance: In the President’s Relentless War on Climate Science, They Fought Back
-
Seaweed blob headed to Florida that smells like rotten eggs shrinks beyond expectation
-
Bankruptcy judge questioned Shilo Sanders' no-show at previous trial
-
Climate Change Worsened Global Inequality, Study Finds
-
A New Study Closes the Case on the Mysterious Rise of a Climate Super-Pollutant
-
Make Fitness a Priority and Save 49% On a Foldable Stationary Bike With Resistance Bands